Honey Lemon Olive Oil Muffins Recipe (2024)

September 17, 2010 by Nicole 33 Comments

I woke up this morning thinking about Sicily. I miss the first house we lived in with the fig, olive, and lemon trees. The figs should be ripe now. There were two olive trees and my dog would constantly chew up then spit out the olives that fell to the ground. They tasted terrible and I don’t know why he kept trying, but he kept it up.

My landlord taught me how to cure the green olives by cracking them with a hammer and submerging them in salted water for weeks. My cutting board is still stained in one spot from cracking olives that afternoon six years ago.

He also taught me to pick the ripe and nearly-ripe olives and cure them by layering olives with salt in a basket and letting them sit for a few weeks until they were shriveled and pungent and delicious. I didn’t speak much Italian, he spoke no English, but we figured it out.

I especially miss the lemon tree. The tree wasn’t technically in our yard, but enough of it reached over the fence that I had access to plenty of fresh lemons whenever I needed them. I needed them often.

Someday I’ll have another house with a lemon tree in the yard. I’d like lots of fruit trees, but the lemons will come first.

And then there’s the olive oil. I didn’t know I loved olive oil until I moved to Sicily. We’d buy it direct from one of the local producers—beautiful, fragrant, unfiltered. It was amazing stuff.

I’m not sure how much olive oil I consumed during the four years we lived there, but it was a lot. That olive oil was so delicious, I couldn’t get enough. I cooked with it, grilled with it, used it as a condiment. I still do, but I have yet to find anything here that compares to the wonderful unfiltered oil we’d buy there.

So as I said, I woke up in the midst of all these memories and longings, swirling thoughts of olive oil and lemons, and I knew I had to make something today that would connect me to that time—something I could smell and taste and share.

I decided to try making muffins with the lemons and olive oil that remind me so much of those years on the island. I had never baked with extra virgin olive oil before, but have heard really great things about citrus and olive oil cakes, so I knew the muffins could be something special.

I also decided to use honey, another ingredient that was a favorite in Sicily.

My first experimental batch failed because I over baked them. I didn’t realize that using honey instead of sugar would cause the muffins to brown so much faster than normal. The first time I checked them, it was already too late! They were brown and dry and crisp but the flavor was delicious, so I knew I was on the right track.

With the second batch, I fooled around with ingredient amounts, replaced part of the honey with granulated sugar, and reduced the oven temperature by 25 degrees. I also checked on them early and often. This batch was a success.

I decided to mix up a quick glaze to brush over the tops of the muffins to intensify the lemon flavor. It’s a tart, thin glaze that soaks into the warm muffin tops and dries as the muffins cool.

The muffins are sweet and flavorful—the lemon flavor is pronounced, the olive oil and honey just linger in the background. The glaze adds the perfect amount of pucker. These are definitely muffins to be shared.

Related Recipes:

• Lemon Shortbread
• EasyLemon Cream Pie<– family favorite!
• Lemon Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches
• Lemon Buttermilk Pound Cake
• My Grandma’s Lemon Jello Cake<– another family favorite!

Around the Web:

• Lemon Tartlets with Olive Oil at Flourishing Foodie
• Meyer Lemon Olive Oil Sugar Cookies at Love & Olive Oil
• Whipped Ricotta with Lemon and Olive Oil at Joy the Baker
• Lemon Olive Oil Poppy Seed Cake from Mountain Mama Cooks
• Lemon Olive Oil Yogurt Cake from Chew Out Loud